Am ___ destroying my enemies when I make friends of them?--Abraham Lincoln, 4 letters
Breaking a tie, for short, 4 letters
Facing sudden death, perhaps, 4 letters
How some NFL games are resolved, 4 letters
Playing a fifth qtr., say, 4 letters
Playing a fourth NHL period, say, 4 letters
Playing an extra period, briefly, 4 letters
Sinead O'Connor album Am ___ Your Girl?, 4 letters
Sinead O'Connor's Am ___ Your Girl?, 4 letters
Still playing (Abbr.), 4 letters
Trying to break a tie, briefly, 4 letters
Trying to get untied, briefly?, 4 letters
Trying to settle a score, for short?, 4 letters
When some deadlocks are resolved, briefly, 4 letters